Home › News › Puzzle: Onyx has one free point left, so which slide ends it?

Puzzle: Onyx has one free point left, so which slide ends it?

Published · By TG, the site operator

A mill is not the only way to win. A side with more than three counters loses as soon as it has no legal move, and the site's rules code checks this straight after each slide. This note is about spotting that win before you reach for a mill. The position is made up for it.

The position

Points are numbered 1 to 24 as the move list shows them: 1 to 8 run clockwise from the top-left corner of the outer square, then 9 to 16 on the middle square and 17 to 24 on the inner square, in the same order. The cross lines are 2-10-18, 4-12-20, 6-14-22 and 8-16-24.

  • Ivory, 9 counters, all placed: 3, 6, 11, 12, 13, 14, 19, 21, 24. Ivory's 11, 12 and 13 stand in a mill.
  • Onyx, 5 counters, all placed: 4, 5, 17, 18, 20. No Onyx counter stands in a mill, and Onyx has none in hand.

Ivory to move. Find the slide that wins at once, without needing a mill. Ivory has eight slides. Seven of them leave Onyx a legal move, and one of those seven closes a mill.

Show the solution

11 → 10. Onyx's counters have one empty neighbour between them: point 10, beside Onyx's 18. Point 10 touches 2, 9, 11 and 18, and of those only Ivory's 11 can reach it in one slide. Once it fills the gap, every Onyx counter is blocked by its own counters or by Ivory's. Onyx has five counters, so it cannot fly, and it has no legal move. The engine ends the game with the note "Opponent cannot move."

Point 11 is left empty, but no Onyx counter touches it.

  • 21 → 22, closing 6-14-22: a mill, and Ivory may take any of Onyx's five counters, since none stands in a mill. Every removal leaves Onyx with moves, so the game goes on.
  • 3 → 2 or 6 → 7: Onyx keeps two legal moves, including a slide of 18 to 10.
  • 24 → 16 or 24 → 23: Onyx keeps two legal moves, including 18 to 10.
  • 14 → 15 or 14 → 22: Onyx keeps one legal move, 18 to 10, so the gap is still open.

How the answer was checked

A script imported the site's own rules file, src/engine.js, without changes. It listed Ivory's eight slides from the position, applied each one, and checked whether the engine ended the game for Onyx or left Onyx with moves. Only 11 → 10 ends the game. The mill slide 21 → 22 was then tried with each of the five possible removals, and Onyx kept moving after every one.

What to take into your games

Before you chase a mill, count the opponent's moves: look at the empty points next to each enemy counter. If they all sit behind your own counters, one slide into the last gap can end the game at once, with no removal at all. The win needs a side with four or more counters, since a side with three may fly.

The rule is in the guide: a side that cannot move also loses. To practise it, play the computer on the game page. On your turn, check whether any enemy counter has an empty neighbour, and whether one of your slides can fill the last one. The game shows the note "Opponent cannot move." when a slide ends the game this way, and Undo takes a move back if you miss it.

Sources

Written by the operator of this site from the sources listed above. Spotted a mistake? Email warmeve.label@gmail.com and it will be corrected.

All nine men's morris news · Play nine men's morris now