Home › News › Puzzle: four counters each, and a mill two slides away

Puzzle: four counters each, and a mill two slides away

Published · By TG, the site operator

Two slides can make a mill, but the first one must also keep the gap out of the other side's reach. With four counters each nobody can fly, so every move follows the lines. Today's puzzle is made up for this note.

The position

Points are numbered as the move list shows them: 1 to 8 run clockwise from the top-left corner of the outer square, then 9 to 16 on the middle square and 17 to 24 on the inner square, in the same order. The cross lines are 2-10-18, 4-12-20, 6-14-22 and 8-16-24.

  • Ivory, four counters, all placed: 6, 12, 20, 22
  • Onyx, four counters, all placed: 13, 14, 19, 21
  • No mill stands. Ivory is to move.

Ivory to move and win a counter by force. No slide closes a mill at once, and Ivory has five slides to choose from.

Try the four-counter ending →

The answer

6 → 5. Ivory's 12 and 20 already stand on the cross line 4-12-20, and point 4 is the gap. The counter on 6 cannot reach 4 in one slide, so the plan takes two slides: 6 → 5 now, then 5 → 4 next turn. Point 4 touches only 3, 5 and 12. Ivory holds 5 and 12, and point 3 is empty, so no Onyx counter can reach 4 in one slide. Onyx has three legal replies: 14 → 6, 14 → 15 and 19 → 18. None closes a mill, and after each one 5 → 4 closes 4-12-20 and Ivory removes an Onyx counter.

The tempting move is 12 → 4, which sits on the line itself. It empties 12, and Onyx slides 13 → 12 into the gap. The other three slides, 6 → 7, 12 → 11 and 22 → 23, each leave Onyx a reply after which Ivory has no mill to close next turn.

How the answer was checked

The rules were run through a Python copy of the rules in the site's src/engine.js, with the game's own legal-move and mill logic. Every Ivory first slide was tried, then every Onyx reply, then every Ivory answer. Only 6 → 5 wins a counter in two turns. A second script re-checked the three Onyx replies, the single point-4 neighbourhood, and the three failing alternatives.

What to take into your games

A line that is one counter short is only a threat if the gap is out of reach. Find the empty point on your line, then count the enemy counters that could slide into it in one move. If none can, the route matters more than the gap. Here the route takes two slides, so the first slide must keep the second one available. Moving a counter off the line you want, as 12 → 4 did, gives the opponent the point you just left.

To practise, play the computer on the game page and watch for the same shape in the moving phase: two of your counters on a line, one empty point, and a counter one slide from it. Undo takes a move back, so you can try the other first slide. The guide sets out the sliding rules.

Sources

Written by the operator of this site from the sources listed above. Spotted a mistake? Email warmeve.label@gmail.com and it will be corrected.

All nine men's morris news · Play nine men's morris now