Puzzle: Onyx is down to three counters, so which slide ends it?
Published · By TG, the site operator
Onyx is down to three counters, and Ivory has five. Three counters can fly, so it is tempting to think Onyx has a way out. The rule that decides this position is simpler: a side with fewer than three counters loses, and the site checks that straight after each removal. This puzzle is made up for this note, and the answer was checked by running the site's own rules code.
The position
- Ivory, five counters: 1, 6, 11, 13, 15
- Onyx, three counters: 4, 10, 12
- Moving phase, Ivory to move. No mill is standing on the board.
Points are numbered as the move list shows them: 1 to 8 run clockwise from the top-left corner of the outer square, 9 to 16 do the same on the middle square, and 17 to 24 on the inner square. Ivory's 13 and 15 already sit on the bottom side of the middle square, so the gap is point 14.
Find the slide that closes the line →
The answer
Slide 6 to 14. Point 6 is the bottom middle of the outer square, and 14 is the bottom middle of the middle square, joined to it by a spoke. The slide closes the line 13, 14, 15, so the site asks Ivory to take a counter.
Onyx has three counters, so whichever one Ivory takes, Onyx is left with two. The game ends on that removal, and the notice reads "Opponent has fewer than three counters." Onyx gets no turn in between, so flying cannot help it.
Why the other moves fail
Ivory has eight legal moves here. Sliding 13 to 14 or 15 to 14 gives up the line you want, and the other five slides (1 to 2, 1 to 8, 6 to 5, 6 to 7 and 15 to 16) close nothing. None of the seven wins within three of Ivory's turns. Only 6 to 14 does.
- The mill is a removal, not a picture: the line matters only because it lets you take a counter.
- Count the opponent's counters before you choose the removal: the game ends at once only when the side left has fewer than three.
Practise the idea
The guide sets out the rule for a side with fewer than three counters, and the flying rule for exactly three. Play a game against the computer and watch the counter total. When the other side is down to three, look for a line with one gap that one of your counters can reach in one slide. That is the shape to aim for.
Sources
- Nine Men's Morris guide: rules, mills and flying — Nine Men's Morris site
Written by the operator of this site from the sources listed above. Spotted a mistake? Email warmeve.label@gmail.com and it will be corrected.