Puzzle: two mills on offer, but a quiet slide wins
Published · By TG, the site operator
On this board a side that cannot move on its turn loses, however many counters it still has. Today's puzzle, a position made up for this note rather than taken from a game, turns on that rule.
How the points are named
The game page prints a number beside each of the 24 points, and the move list uses the same numbers (a slide reads 19 → 18). When you play Ivory, 1 is the top-left corner of the outer square and the numbers run clockwise: 1 to 3 along the top, 4 mid-right, 5 bottom right, 6 bottom middle, 7 bottom left, 8 mid-left. The middle square is 9 to 16 and the inner square 17 to 24 in the same pattern; the cross lines join 2-10-18, 4-12-20, 6-14-22 and 8-16-24.
The position
- Ivory, 7 counters: 4, 8, 11, 13, 14, 16, 19
- Onyx, 5 counters: 1, 2, 3, 9, 10
- All counters are placed and neither side is down to three, so every turn is a slide along a line.
Ivory to move and win at once. Two moves close a mill: 4 → 12 completes 11-12-13, and 16 → 15 completes 13-14-15. Is either of them the answer?
Show the solution
19 → 18. Look at Onyx's counters before your own. The ones on 1, 2 and 3 are hemmed in by each other and by Ivory on 4 and 8. The one on 9 is stuck between 10 and Ivory's 16. Only the counter on 10 has a way out, the step to 18. Sliding 19 to 18 shuts that door, and the point it leaves, 19, touches no Onyx counter. Onyx has no legal move and loses with five counters still on the board.
Both mills are traps, because each moves a guard: 4 → 12 uncovers point 4 next to Onyx's 3, and 16 → 15 uncovers 16 next to Onyx's 9. The removal does not help. Onyx's 1, 2 and 3 form a mill, so they are protected while 9 and 10 are not, and taking either of those still leaves Onyx at least two legal moves.
How the answer was checked
The position was loaded into the rules code the game page runs, and all 12 of Ivory's legal slides were played, each mill followed by every removal the rules allow. Only 19 → 18 ends the game; after any other choice Onyx has one to three legal replies. A second script that rewrites the rules from scratch agreed.
What to take into your own games
The guide warns that a player who builds a line and neglects the neighbouring points can run out of moves as the board fills. Turn that round: on a crowded board, count your opponent's moves before you grab a mill. If they have only one or two, closing those exits can be worth more than a removal. Check the midpoints of the middle square first: 10, 12, 14 and 16 are the only points with four neighbours, and Onyx's last exit here ran from 10.
Two limits. A blockade cannot beat a side with exactly three counters, because those may fly to any empty point. And it only works once both sides have placed all nine, since a counter still in hand can go on any empty point.
To practise, play the computer on the game page and, once all counters are down, count the opponent's moves each turn; Undo takes your move back so you can try the other idea. The Daily puzzle there offers a close-a-mill position each day.
Sources
- Why a mill is a removal, not a picture — Nine Men's Morris (this site), 2 October 2026
- Nine Men's Morris — game page and rules summary — Nine Men's Morris (this site)
Written by the operator of this site from the sources listed above. Spotted a mistake? Email warmeve.label@gmail.com and it will be corrected.