The Zwickmühle: a mill on every move, and how to stop it
Published · By TG, the site operator
Our guide notes that a mill can be opened and closed again, each closing removing another counter. With one mill that takes two turns. German has a name for a faster shape, Doppelmühle or Zwickmühle: two of your lines have their third points next to each other, and one counter steps back and forth between those points, opening one mill and closing the other on every move.
The word has outgrown the board. Duden and the DWDS dictionary give this position as its first meaning and, in everyday speech, a tight spot with no apparent way out. The DWDS dates the game sense to the 17th century and explains the shift: what is a double way out for one player looks hopeless to the other. Both link the first part of the word to an old form of "two".
The shape on this board
Points use the numbers printed on the board, seen from Ivory's side: 1 to 8 clockwise from the top-left corner of the outer square, then 9 to 16 and 17 to 24 the same way on the middle and inner squares. A made-up position, all counters placed:
- Ivory, 5 counters: 9, 10, 11, 17, 19
- Onyx, 5 counters: 1, 2, 3, 6, 15
- Ivory to move.
Sliding 10 → 18 opens Ivory's mill 9-10-11 and closes 17-18-19; next turn 18 → 10 closes 9-10-11 again. Each closing is a removal, so left alone Onyx loses a counter every Ivory turn.
Why it is harder to stop than one mill
Opening a single mill removes nothing, so the defender gets a turn to fill the empty point, if a counter stands next to it. In a Zwickmühle the opening move is also a closing move: the removal comes first and can take the very counter you meant to block with. German Wikipedia's strategy section says the owner can thin out the opponent's counters quickly with no effective reply, so prevention comes first.
Four ways to stop it
- Do not let it form. Look for two enemy lines whose missing points touch, and occupy one of them in time. An Onyx counter on 18 keeps 17-18-19 shut while it stays.
- Block with a counter that cannot be taken. With the shuttle on 10, every neighbour of 18 is Ivory's, so Onyx can only plug 10, from 2. After 10 → 18 Ivory must remove 6 or 15: the counter on 2 is in Onyx's mill 1-2-3, protected while Onyx has counters outside a mill. Onyx slides 2 → 10 and the shuttle stops. Give Onyx 2, 3, 6, 15 and 24 instead and Ivory removes 2; nothing else reaches 10, and 18 → 10 closes the next mill whatever Onyx plays.
- Hit the open line. While the shuttle sits on 10, its partners on 17 and 19 are not in a mill. Close a mill of your own and take one; what remains is a single, slow mill.
- Fly into the gap. With exactly three counters you may move to any empty point. Give Onyx only 2, 3, 6 and 15: Ivory's removal leaves three, and Onyx can fly onto 10.
Each of these lines was played through the rules code the game page runs.
Practise it here
Against the computer, check after every placement whether either side has two lines with touching gaps; if you missed one, Undo takes your move back so you can try the blocking point. Online games have no Undo, so build the habit first. Start on the game page.
Sources
- Why a mill is a removal, not a picture — Nine Men's Morris (this site), 2 October 2026
- Nine Men's Morris — game page and rules summary — Nine Men's Morris (this site)
- Zwickmühle (Bedeutungen, Herkunft) — Duden
- Zwickmühle (Bedeutungen; Etymologie nach Pfeifer, Etymologisches Wörterbuch) — DWDS – Digitales Wörterbuch der deutschen Sprache
- Mühle (Spiel), section Strategie — Wikipedia (German)
Written by the operator of this site from the sources listed above. Spotted a mistake? Email warmeve.label@gmail.com and it will be corrected.