Puzzle: a double threat while placing, but which corner first?
Published · By TG, the site operator
Our last puzzle was about sliding; this one is from the placing phase. While counters can go on any empty point, one threat is easy to stop: your opponent fills the gap. Winning a counter takes two threats at once, and the counter you force your opponent to place must not hand them a threat. The position is made up.
The position
Points use the numbers printed on the board, seen from Ivory's side: 1 to 8 run clockwise from the top-left corner of the outer square, then 9 to 16 and 17 to 24 the same way on the middle and inner squares; the cross lines are 2-10-18, 4-12-20, 6-14-22 and 8-16-24.
- Ivory, six placed, three to come: 3, 5, 9, 13, 14, 24
- Onyx, six placed, three to come: 4, 10, 11, 15, 16, 22
- Nothing has been taken, no mill stands, and neither side can close one with its next counter.
Ivory to place her seventh counter and win a counter by force. No single placement threatens two mills yet. Hint: Ivory holds the corners 3 and 5, and the opposite side, 7-8-1, is empty.
Show the solution
7. It threatens to close 5-6-7 on 6, so Onyx must block there or lose a counter at once. That counter is harmless, because the other line through 6, 6-14-22, already holds Ivory's 14. Now Ivory places on 1, threatening 2 (for 1-2-3) and 8 (for 7-8-1) together. Onyx can fill only one gap:
- Onyx on 8: Ivory closes 1-2-3 on 2 and may take any Onyx counter, since none stands in a mill.
- Onyx on 2: this lines up with Onyx's 10 and threatens 18. Ivory closes 7-8-1 on 8 and must take 2 or 10. Otherwise Onyx's last counter closes 2-10-18 on 18 and wins one back.
If Onyx answers 7 with a threat of its own, such as 12 aiming at 20, Ivory closes 5-6-7 on 6 and removes one of the two counters behind it.
Starting from the other corner fails. After 1, Onyx's forced block on 2 joins its 10 and threatens 18; if Ivory forks on 7 anyway, Onyx closes 2-10-18 and removes the counter on 7, which ends both threats. After 2 or 6 the forced block lands on 1 or 7 and spoils the line 7-8-1.
With 7, Ivory keeps all nine counters and Onyx has at most eight when the last counter is placed.
How the answer was checked
Using the rules code the game page runs, every line was played out to the last placement, including every allowed removal. Only 7 guarantees Ivory a lead; after each of the other eleven placements Onyx can finish placing level or ahead. A second script, written separately, agreed. The prize is one counter for the sliding phase, not a won game.
What to take into your games
While placing, a threat tells your opponent where their next counter goes. Before you make one, look at the other line through the point you are sending them to. If they already have a counter on that line, you hand them a threat; if you have one there, the block gives them nothing.
The guide explains why a mill is worth the counter it removes. To practise, play the computer on the game page: the playbook panel lists placements by point number ("Placed at 7"), and Undo lets you try the other corner. Some Daily puzzles there ask you to place a counter to close a mill.
Sources
- Why a mill is a removal, not a picture — Nine Men's Morris (this site), 2 October 2026
- Nine Men's Morris — game page and rules summary — Nine Men's Morris (this site)
Written by the operator of this site from the sources listed above. Spotted a mistake? Email warmeve.label@gmail.com and it will be corrected.