Home › News › Puzzle: you closed a mill, so which counter do you take?

Puzzle: you closed a mill, so which counter do you take?

Published · By TG, the site operator

Closing a mill is half a move; the other half is choosing which counter to take. Against a side about to drop to three, that choice often decides the game. The position is made up for this note.

The position

Points use the move list's numbers, seen from Ivory's side: 1 to 8 run clockwise from the top-left corner of the outer square (7 is bottom left, 8 mid-left), then 9 to 16 and 17 to 24 the same way on the middle and inner squares. The cross lines are 2-10-18, 4-12-20, 6-14-22 and 8-16-24.

  • Ivory, 6 counters: 2, 3, 5, 6, 8, 12
  • Onyx, 4 counters: 7, 13, 18, 23
  • All counters are placed and no mill stands, so every Onyx counter may be taken.

Ivory to move and win in two turns, whatever Onyx does. Two slides close a mill: 8 → 1 completes 1-2-3, and 12 → 4 completes 3-4-5. Either way Onyx falls to three counters and may then fly to any empty point, so a single threat will simply be blocked. Pick the slide, then pick the counter.

Show the solution

12 → 4, removing the counter on 7. Onyx's 7 was doing a defender's job: it sat in the gap of Ivory's line 5-6-7. With it gone, Ivory's counter on 8 touches two gaps at once. Sliding to 1 closes 1-2-3; sliding to 7 closes 5-6-7.

Onyx now has 13, 18 and 23. No two of them share a line, so even flying it cannot close a mill of its own next turn. It can fill 1 or 7, not both, and Ivory slides 8 into the other gap. Onyx is left with two counters and loses.

  • 12 → 4, taking 13, 18 or 23: Onyx's 7 still blocks 5-6-7, and Onyx flies a counter to 1, for example 18 → 1. Ivory has no mill to close next turn.
  • 8 → 1, taking 7: the counter that was meant to hit both gaps has gone to 1. Onyx flies 13 → 4 into 3-4-5, and the win takes at least one turn longer.
  • 8 → 1, taking anything else: Onyx flies 7 → 4 and again no mill follows.

How the answer was checked

A script built on an unchanged copy of the rules code the game page runs tried all 16 Ivory turns, counting each removal as a separate choice, and every Onyx reply to them. Only 12 → 4 with the removal of 7 wins on Ivory's second turn; after it, every one of Onyx's 45 replies loses to Ivory's next slide.

What to take into your games

When you close a mill, look first at opponent counters sitting in the gaps of your own lines: taking such a blocker can turn one threat into two. Against three counters, which may fly, only a double threat wins, and if two of theirs already share a line, that pair is the threat to break instead.

The protection rule matters too: a counter standing in a mill cannot be taken while its owner has one outside a mill, so the blocker you want may be out of reach. The guide explains it. To practise, play the computer on the game page and read the move list after each capture (it shows lines such as "Removed point 7"). Undo takes your move back so you can try another removal; online games against a random opponent have no Undo.

Sources

Written by the operator of this site from the sources listed above. Spotted a mistake? Email warmeve.label@gmail.com and it will be corrected.

All nine men's morris news · Play nine men's morris now