Nünistei: Nine Men's Morris in German-speaking lands
Published · By TG, the site operator
Nine Men's Morris has many names. The German Wikipedia article on the game gives the Swiss name as Nünistei or Nünizie, and it traces the game's history in German-speaking lands in a way that is useful for a player. The picture is patchy, and the article is candid about where the evidence is thin.
Early traces
Mill patterns are scratched into stone in many places, the article notes, at least since the Neolithic. Dating them is the problem. The patterns on the roof slabs of the Sethos temple at el-Qurna, built in the 14th century BC, cannot be dated and probably come from later times, and the article suspects that many carvings had a sacred or protective purpose rather than a game. A better-documented case is the Aachen throne of Charlemagne, around 800, which has a mill pattern on a marble slab. Whether that slab ever lay flat as a board is unclear.
Written evidence comes later. The Libro de los juegos of Alfonso X of Castile and León, from the 13th century, is the oldest European-language description of the small mill, the version with three counters each. The Goslar board is more local: a mill board on a house in Goslar, recorded in a 1996 article by Friedrich Berger.
A round mill that probably never existed
In 1918 Carl Blümlein read the Roman wheel-shaped patterns as a round form of the mill, which he called the Rundmühle. Later research has largely refuted this, and the article concludes that the round mill probably never existed. The lesson applies to any old board. A pattern carved on stone shows lines, not rules. A game needs a known set of moves and a second player who agrees to them, and the rules are the part that is lost.
Clubs and championships
Several attempts to found a German club with regular meetings failed, according to the article, so the strongest German players now meet mostly online. Switzerland has the more settled scene. The Club de Charret at Granges-Marnand was founded in 1974 in French-speaking Switzerland, and the Mühlespielverein Bern in 1978. The article says players from Bern won nearly all major international tournaments between 1996 and 2012. The European Championship has been held since 1996, and was in Lenk, Switzerland, until 2004. The World Mühlespiel Federation (WMD) sets the rules and governs tournaments; the article gives no German or Swiss federation of its own.
What the rules look like in play
Tournament rules are not spelled out in the article, so this site does not claim to follow them exactly. The site's game uses the rules that matter most to a casual player: flying at exactly three counters, protection for counters in a mill, and draws by threefold repetition or after 100 plies without a capture.
To see the old boards in action, open the game page. Choose Ivory, which places first, or Onyx, where the computer starts, and set the computer to Easy, Normal or Hard. Use Undo to take back a placement and try the other point, and see how the placing choices change the board.
Sources
- Mühle (Spiel) — Wikipedia (German)
- Nine Men's Morris — game page and rules summary — Nine Men's Morris (this site)
Written by the operator of this site from the sources listed above. Spotted a mistake? Email warmeve.label@gmail.com and it will be corrected.