Home › News › Puzzle: three counters can fly, so which move makes a mill Onyx cannot stop?

Puzzle: three counters can fly, so which move makes a mill Onyx cannot stop?

Published · By TG, the site operator

A side with exactly three counters may fly: it can move to any empty point, not only a neighbour. That makes a threat hard to stop, because the flying counter can finish a line from almost anywhere. Today's puzzle is made up for this note.

The position

Points are numbered as the move log numbers them: 1 is the top-left corner of the outer square, the numbers run clockwise through 8, then 9 to 16 on the middle square and 17 to 24 on the inner square in the same pattern. The cross lines join 2-10-18, 4-12-20, 6-14-22 and 8-16-24, and the bottom side of the inner square is 21-22-23.

Ivory to move and win a counter by force. Which counter should fly?

Show the solution

11 → 23. The counter on 23 sits on the inner bottom side beside Ivory's 21, so Ivory now holds 21 and 23 with 22 empty. Next turn the flying counter on 2 can fly to 22 and complete 21-22-23. Onyx cannot stop it. The point 22 touches 14, 21 and 23; two of those are Ivory's, and no Onyx counter stands on 14 to slide in. Onyx has eleven legal replies: 1 → 8, 10 → 9, 10 → 11, 12 → 4, 12 → 11, 12 → 13, 12 → 20, 18 → 17, 18 → 19, 24 → 16 and 24 → 17. None of them forms a mill, and after each one 2 → 22 closes the mill and Ivory removes an Onyx counter.

The tempting move is 2 → 22, which also gives Ivory two counters on the bottom side. It fails in two ways. Onyx can slide 24 → 23 to block the gap. Or Onyx can play 1 → 2, which closes its own mill 2-10-18 on the point Ivory has just left, and removes an Ivory counter. No other fly works either: after each of them Onyx has a reply that stops Ivory's mill, or closes its own mill first.

How the answer was checked

Every legal move from the position was played through the rules code the game page runs, with each Onyx reply and Ivory's answer, including every removal the rules allow. Only 11 → 23 wins a counter by force. A second script, written separately from the board description, agreed on that move and on the list of Onyx's replies.

What to take into your own games

Once a side is down to three counters, look for a line with two of its counters and an empty third point. Then ask two questions: can the opponent slide a counter into that gap, and does the opponent have a mill of its own ready? Also check the point you leave. Moving off a point can complete an opponent's line, as 2 → 22 did here.

To practise, play the computer on the game page at Normal or Hard, and wait for one side to reach three counters. Then list each flying move that makes a threat, and check the opponent's slides into the gap. Undo takes a move back, so you can try the other fly before the computer answers. The guide explains the flying rule.

Sources

Written by the operator of this site from the sources listed above. Spotted a mistake? Email warmeve.label@gmail.com and it will be corrected.

All nine men's morris news · Play nine men's morris now