Home › News › Placing phase: Onyx places last, but Ivory slides first

Placing phase: Onyx places last, but Ivory slides first

Published · By TG, the site operator

Most of the placing phase is about lines: which point closes a mill, and which one blocks the opponent. The counters you drop also set up the movement phase, and one part of that is simple turn order. Each side places nine counters and Ivory places first, so Onyx makes the eighteenth and last drop. Then the turn comes back to Ivory, and Ivory makes the first slide. That first move is a small advantage, and it is easy to forget while you chase a mill.

Count the turns

Turns alternate from start to finish. Ivory has the odd-numbered turns and Onyx the even ones, whether a turn is a placement or a slide. A removal does not add a turn: when a mill is closed, the side that closed it removes an opposing counter, and the turn then passes as usual. The site's rules file, which the game runs, works this way. To check it, random games were played through that file with random moves for both sides. Every game that reached the slide phase had Onyx make the eighteenth placement and Ivory make the first slide.

What that means on the board

A side that places last has the least choice over where its final counter goes, because it must fit whatever space the other side has left. Ivory, moving first in the slide phase, gets the first use of the position the placing phase leaves behind. This does not decide a game, and the board can change the answer. Before you spend your last few counters on a mill that the opponent can block, check which of your counters can slide next.

Place for exits, not only for lines

The guide warns that a player who builds one pretty line and ignores the neighbouring points can find that no move is left when the board fills. Neighbour counts differ across this board. A corner point touches two others. A point at the middle of a side of the outer or inner square touches three. A point at the middle of a side of the middle square touches four, because it also lies on a cross line. So a counter on the middle square gives more slide options than one in a corner, as long as those neighbours stay empty when you need them.

How to practise it

  1. After the first few placements, count the empty neighbours of each point you are considering.
  2. Ask which of your counters could slide next turn, and which point each slide would empty.
  3. When a mill is closed and locked in, compare it with a mill you can open and close later. The guide explains that a mill you can reopen gives repeated removals, so keeping one open can be worth more than closing it now.

To try this, open the game page, play the computer, and use Undo to take back a placement and compare. The rules are set out in the guide. Ivory places first, and Ivory also makes the first slide, in every game.

Sources

Written by the operator of this site from the sources listed above. Spotted a mistake? Email warmeve.label@gmail.com and it will be corrected.

All nine men's morris news · Play nine men's morris now