Protected counters: a mill is safe only while a loose counter exists
Published · By TG, the site operator
Most of a mill's value comes from the counter it lets you take, and the rules decide which counters are open to that. The short version: a counter standing in a mill is protected only while the opponent has a counter outside a mill. This note explains the rule with two made-up positions, both checked by running the site's own rules code.
The rule in plain terms
When your placement or slide closes a mill, you remove one opposing counter. If any opposing counter stands outside a mill, you must pick one of those. Only when every opposing counter already stands in a mill may you pick from the mills. A mill here means three of one side's counters on a single marked line.
Example one: one loose counter spoils the shelter
Ivory has just closed the top side of the outer square, 1-2-3. Onyx has three counters on 5, 6 and 7, which form a mill of its own, and a fourth counter on 13 that stands alone. Ivory's removal choice is short: only the counter on 13 may be taken. The three counters in Onyx's mill are safe, even though Ivory has just scored.
Try a removal with a loose counter on the board →
Example two: when every counter is in a mill
Now give Onyx two mills, 5-6-7 and 17-18-19, and no counter outside them. The same closing move for Ivory now allows any of the six Onyx counters. The protection has not gone; it simply has nothing left to shelter. That is why the guide says protection applies only while a non-mill counter exists.
What this means in your games
- Before you close a mill, list the opposing counters outside any mill. Those are your only legal targets, and the list is often shorter than it looks.
- When the mill you want to break is protected, find the loose counter that shelters it. Once the last loose counter is gone, the whole mill is open to your next removal.
Practise it on the board
Open the game page and play the computer. In the moving phase, look for a mill you can close, and count the opposing counters outside mills before you slide. Undo takes a move back, so you can try another slide and see how the removal choice changes. The guide sets out the full rule with its examples.
Sources
- Why a mill is a removal, not a picture (guide) — Nine Men's Morris site, 2 October 2026
- Nine Men's Morris game page — Nine Men's Morris site
Written by the operator of this site from the sources listed above. Spotted a mistake? Email warmeve.label@gmail.com and it will be corrected.