Home › News › Puzzle: both sides have a double threat, and Ivory places first

Puzzle: both sides have a double threat, and Ivory places first

Published · By TG, the site operator

Two double threats can face each other on the board, and the side that places first decides which one lands. This puzzle is made up for this note. Nothing has been taken and no mill stands. Each side has one point from which a single counter would threaten two mills at once.

The position

Points are numbered as on the game page: 1 to 8 run clockwise from the top-left corner of the outer square, 9 to 16 are the middle square and 17 to 24 the inner square, in the same pattern. The cross lines are 2-10-18, 4-12-20, 6-14-22 and 8-16-24.

Ivory is to place. Neither side has two counters on a line with the third point empty, so no mill can be closed with the next counter.

Place your counters and count the double threats →

Which placement wins a counter?

Ivory's answer is 15. It threatens two mills at once: 14, which completes 13-14-15, and 9, which completes 15-16-9. Point 9 is also Onyx's double-threat point, because with 11 and 17 an Onyx counter there would threaten 10 and 1.

In the main line Onyx blocks on 9, which makes its own two threats. Ivory places on 14 and closes 13-14-15. The removal may take any Onyx counter, since none stands in a mill, and Ivory takes the counter on 9, the one making both threats. Onyx places its last counter, and placing ends with nine Ivory counters on the board to Onyx's eight.

The other placements

Seven placements leave Ivory a counter behind when placing ends: 1, 10, 12, 18, 19, 22 and 23. Points 9 and 14 hold the count level. Taking 9 stops Onyx's double threat but wins nothing; the double threat on 15 is the only placement that forces Onyx to lose a counter.

How the answer was checked

A script imported the site's own rules file, the one the game page runs, without changes. It played every placement and every removal the rules allow, for both sides, to the end of the placing phase, and compared the counters left on the board. Only 15 gives Ivory a lead. Every Onyx reply to it leaves Ivory one counter ahead. A second check followed the main line move by move.

What to take into your games

When both sides hold a double-threat point, check whose is ready first. A block is also a placement, and blocking the other side's point first may only hold the count level. A mill's removal can take the counter that made the threat. Here the counter on 9 was taken because it was making two threats, and the rules allowed it because no Onyx counter stood in a mill.

Practise it on the board

The game starts from the empty board, so a position like this comes up only in play. Open the game page, choose Ivory, and play the computer on Normal or Hard. When each side has two counters left, count the double-threat points for both sides before you place, and use Undo to try the other placement. The guide explains why a mill is worth the counter it removes.

Sources

Written by the operator of this site from the sources listed above. Spotted a mistake? Email warmeve.label@gmail.com and it will be corrected.

All nine men's morris news · Play nine men's morris now