Home › News › Threefold repetition and the 100-ply rule: how the site counts a draw

Threefold repetition and the 100-ply rule: how the site counts a draw

Published · By TG, the site operator

A draw on this site comes from one of two counts: the same position for the third time, or 100 plies without a capture. The guide states both in one sentence. The rules code shows exactly what is counted, which matters when you are ahead and want to avoid a shuffle, or behind and hoping for one.

What counts as the same position

A position is the whole board together with the side to move. Positions are recorded only once placing has ended, so the position reached by the last placement is the first entry, even though no slide has been made yet. The third entry of the same position ends the game as a draw.

A loop worked through the rules

Take the position reached when Onyx makes its ninth and last placement, on 13. Ivory is to move and holds 1, 3, 5, 7, 10, 12, 19, 21 and 23. Onyx holds 2, 4, 6, 9, 13, 14, 16, 18 and 24. No mill stands. Each side now moves one counter out and back:

  1. Ivory slides 1 to 8.
  2. Onyx slides 14 to 22.
  3. Ivory slides 8 to 1.
  4. Onyx slides 22 to 14.

After four slides the board is the one it started from, with Ivory to move. That is the second entry. After four more slides it is the third, and the game ends as a draw on the eighth slide. Neither side has made a mistake, so a side that wants to keep playing has to change the shape of its position, not just wait for the other side to run out of ideas.

Try the four-slide loop on the board →

How to break a repetition

The hundred-ply count

The second rule is a plain tally. Each slide by either side adds one ply, and a capture sets the tally back to zero. At 100 the game ends as a draw. We tested this on a made-up position with the tally at 98: the next slide brought it to 99 and the game went on, and the slide after that ended it as a draw. Because the tally counts both sides, a long, quiet exchange with no capture can end in a draw even when no position has repeated.

Practise it on the board

Open the game page, choose Ivory, and set the computer to Normal. Once all counters are down, look for a slide that returns the board to a position you have already seen. Undo takes your move back, so you can compare the repeat with the alternative. The guide sets out both draw rules next to the mill and flying rules.

Sources

Written by the operator of this site from the sources listed above. Spotted a mistake? Email warmeve.label@gmail.com and it will be corrected.

All nine men's morris news · Play nine men's morris now