Puzzle: Onyx's last counter leaves Ivory with no move
Published · By TG, the site operator
Most placing talk is about lines: which point closes a mill, and which one blocks the other side. The last counter of the placing phase can end the game without any mill. Ivory places first, so Onyx makes the eighteenth and last placement, and then Ivory must slide. A side that cannot move also loses. This puzzle is made up for this note.
The position
Points use the numbers printed on the board, seen from Ivory's side: 1 to 8 run clockwise from the top-left corner of the outer square, then 9 to 16 and 17 to 24 the same way on the middle and inner squares. The cross lines are 2-10-18, 4-12-20, 6-14-22 and 8-16-24.
- Ivory, nine counters, all placed: 3, 5, 6, 7, 13, 14, 15, 21, 22
- Onyx, eight placed, one in hand: 2, 4, 8, 12, 17, 18, 20, 23
- Onyx is to place. Ivory has three mills standing (5-6-7, 13-14-15 and 6-14-22), and Onyx has one (4-12-20).
Onyx to place its last counter and win at once. Which point?
Place Onyx's last counter and count Ivory's moves →
The answer
Show the solution
16. After this placement the six empty points are 1, 9, 10, 11, 19 and 24. Each one touches only Onyx counters or other empty points: 1 touches 2 and 8, 9 touches 10 and 16, 10 touches 2, 9, 11 and 18, 11 touches 10 and 12, 19 touches 18 and 20, and 24 touches 16, 17 and 23. No Ivory counter stands next to an empty point, so Ivory has no slide. Ivory has nine counters and cannot fly, so the game ends at once with the note "Opponent cannot move."
The other placements do not win:
- 1, 9 or 11: no mill, and Ivory keeps exactly one slide, 15 to 16. The game goes on.
- 10, 19 or 24: each closes an Onyx mill (2-10-18, 17-18-19 or 17-23-24). Onyx may remove only Ivory's 3 or 21, because the other Ivory counters stand in mills. Removing 3 leaves Ivory one slide; removing 21 leaves two.
How the answer was checked
A script imported the site's own rules file, src/engine.js, without changes. It set up the position, tried all seven empty points for Onyx's last counter, and for each mill played every removal the rules allow. A second check, rebuilt by hand from the board description rather than from the rules file, found the same neighbours, mills and answer.
What to take into your games
The side that places last has the final say over exits. Before you drop a counter, count the opponent's legal moves, and ask which empty point, if filled, leaves none. Here one point does it, and a mill that looks stronger does not. The moving-phase note explains how to count exits move by move.
The idea has a limit. A side with exactly three counters may fly to any empty point, so a blockade only works against a side with more than three.
Practise it on the board
Open the game page, choose Onyx (where the computer starts), and set the computer to Normal. The site starts from an empty board, so this position comes up only in play: when the placing phase nears its end, count the empty neighbours of the opponent's counters before each drop. Undo takes your move back, so you can try the other point. The guide sets out the rule that a side which cannot move also loses.
Sources
- Mills guide: rules, flying and draws — Nine Men's Morris site, 9 November 2026
- Nine Men's Morris: play the computer — Nine Men's Morris site, 9 November 2026
Written by the operator of this site from the sources listed above. Spotted a mistake? Email warmeve.label@gmail.com and it will be corrected.