A mill with nothing to take: when closing a line removes no counter
Published · By TG, the site operator
On this site a closed mill is a removal, not a picture: the closing player takes one opposing counter. A removal needs a target, though, and the rules code checks for one before it allows a capture. So a line that closes while the opponent has no counter on the board scores nothing. This note explains that case with a made-up position, checked by running the site's rules code.
What the code checks
After a placement or slide puts a counter on a point, the code asks whether that counter now stands in a mill. If it does, it asks one more question: does the other side have a counter on the board? Only when both answers are yes does the turn become a removal. Counters still in hand do not count. A side with counters to place but none on the board gives nothing to take.
A position with nothing to take
Ivory has counters on points 1 and 2 and one counter still to place. Onyx has no counter on the board and three still to place. Ivory's last counter goes on point 3, which completes the top side of the outer square, 1-2-3. By the site's definition that is a mill: three counters of one side on a marked line.
The placement is legal and the mill is formed, but there is nothing to remove. The turn passes to Onyx, which must place a counter. The move list shows only the placement, "Placed at 3", with no "Removed point" entry, and the notice reads "Place your next counter."
Close a line on the board and watch the move list →
Why the rule matters
Ivory has neither gained a counter nor lost one. The three counters on 1, 2 and 3 stay in a mill, and that matters later. A counter in a mill may be taken only when every opposing counter is already in a mill, as the protected counters note explains. The line also cannot reopen during placing, because counters do not move until all nine are on the board. It can only help once Onyx has a counter on the board and a later mill closes.
The position is rare. Reaching it from an empty board takes a long run of removals by Onyx, so it is a teaching case, not a common game.
What it means in your games
- Before you count a line as a threat, check the other side's board. If it has no counter there, closing the line takes nothing.
- Compare the placement with its alternatives. A point that blocks an opposing line, or prepares a second threat for later, may be worth more than a line that scores nothing now.
- Remember that a counter still in hand is not a target. Only counters on the board can be removed.
Practise it on the site
Open the game page and play the computer on Easy. Watch the move list: a placement reads "Placed at" followed by a point number, and a removal reads "Removed point". Use Undo to take back a placement and compare the notice after each one. The guide sets out the removal rule with examples, including the case where every opposing counter stands in a mill.
Sources
- Why a mill is a removal, not a picture (guide) — Nine Men's Morris site, 2 October 2026
- Nine Men's Morris game page — Nine Men's Morris site
Written by the operator of this site from the sources listed above. Spotted a mistake? Email warmeve.label@gmail.com and it will be corrected.